Eye stab yob loses appeal

PUBLISHED: 14:49 23 January 2008 | UPDATED: 11:28 01 July 2010

A YOUNG thug who killed a friend in a dispute over a taxi fare, plunging a kitchen knife into his eye socket, has failed in an Appeal Court challenge to his indefinite prison sentence.

A YOUNG thug who killed a friend in a dispute over a taxi fare, plunging a kitchen knife into his eye socket, has failed in an Appeal Court challenge to his indefinite prison sentence.

Craig Griffin, 21, of Thursley Road, Mottingham stabbed Barry Johnson with such force that the blade cut through his skull and penetrated his brain.

He was convicted of manslaughter at the Old Bailey in May 2007 and sentenced to indefinite imprisonment for public protection (IPP).

After an appeal to three top judges at the Criminal Appeal Court last Friday, Griffin was told that the tough sentence - almost identical to a life term - would stand.

The sentence means the courts consider that he poses such a danger to the public that he must be locked up indefinitely, until he is assessed as no longer being a risk by the Parole Board.

Mr Justice Saunders, who sat with Lord Justice Tuckey and Mr Justice Coulson, said Griffin's suggestion that he did not realise the consequences of his actions meant he potentially posed even more of a danger.

Griffin had been with Mr Johnson at his home in Mottingham on the night of the killing and had taken some of the victim's money to get a taxi home. Prosecutors said the arrangement had been that the taxi driver would take Griffin to Bromley, but then buy some cigarettes and deliver them to Mr Johnson.

But, shortly after leaving, Griffin returned to Mr Johnson's home with the cigarettes and an argument broke out about the rest of the cash.

A knife, taken from the kitchen, was used, possibly by both men, and Mr Johnson was killed by stab wounds to the back and eye socket.

Griffin, who received a cut consistent with a knife wound, said Mr Johnson had first attacked him with the blade, but he had then taken it from him and struck out. Initially, Griffin was charged with murder, but, when the jury failed to reach a verdict, they instead convicted him of manslaughter and he was jailed.

Lawyers representing Griffin argued that the judge was wrong to sentence Griffin on the basis of him having been provoked and should instead have done so on the basis of lack of intent to kill.

Had he done so, he would have been less likely to consider that Griffin was dangerous enough to justify an open-ended term, it was argued.

But, dismissing the appeal, Mr Justice Saunders said the trial judge had been perfectly entitled to come to his own conclusions about Griffin's dangerousness.

"In our judgment, on a proper analysis, the judge's findings are unassailable," he said.

"Not only did he have all the relevant factors in mind, but he had the great benefit of observing Griffin at his trial and hearing his evidence."


Latest news

Saturday, November 17, 2018

Wondering what the weather has in store for us this weekend? Watch our Met Office video forecast.

Friday, November 16, 2018

Ravens beaten by Peterborough United in FA Cup last weekend despite brave effort

Friday, November 16, 2018

Now back from recording the second series of All Together Now, Brit School teacher and Bromley local Georg Tormann is now warming up for Christmas with his Beckenham-based choir.

Thursday, November 15, 2018

Parents sporting ‘Say Yes To Bullers’ T-shirts packed into Bromley Civic Centre for the closing of a planning inquiry into a proposed school.

Wednesday, November 14, 2018

There are three weeks left to donate to this year’s Christmas Charity Appeal and help to give families in need some happy memories around the festive period.

Tuesday, November 13, 2018

Detectives investigating the fatal stabbing of 22-year-old Ayodeji Habeeb Azeez in Anerley have charged a 23-year-old man with murder.

Most read

Digital Edition

Read the Bromley Times e-edition today

Newsletter Sign Up

Bromley Times twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Show Job Lists

Family Notices 24